Hilary Swank and Michelle Williams: Which Witch is Breast?

Director Sam Raimi (Spider-Man,The Evil Dead) is known for his stubborn attachment to his casting choices, and now he's got his sights set on Hilary Swank for his upcoming big-budget fantasy Oz: The Great and Powerful. Hilary would be playing the Wicked Witch of the East, older sister to Mila Kunis' Wicked Witch of the West.

But the studio suits aren't exactly under Hilary's spell- fearing the box-office curse that has plagued Swank lately, they've proposed Blue Valentine's Michelle Williams for the role instead. Now it looks like Raimi's settling in for a long battle with the studio, leading us here at Skin Central to wonder: which witch is more deserving of the pointy hat? Let's gaze into Mr. Skin's crystal ball of nudity:

When she was just an up-and-coming young hottie, Hilary Swank won her first Oscar for her daring performance in Boys Don't Cry(1999). After furry taco night with Chloe Sevigny, Hilary proved she was a girl in a scene that makes the boys cry with confusion every time- it's a sad and disturbing scene of rape, but we get to see Hilary's bush. Since then, Hilary's won another Oscar and has become pretty skingy with her onscreen nudity- the breast is her buttcrack in The Black Dahlia (2006).

For your other hand, we've got indie darling Michelle Williams. This baby-faced babe (and Mr. Skin Nudity Hall-of-Famer) has shown her sweet teats in five different films, starting with her lesbian romp with Chloe Sevigny in If These Walls Could Talk 2(2000). We got a lingering, well-lit look at Michelle's mams in Incendiary(2008), followed by an emotionally intense perv-formance in Blue Valentine(2010) that scored Michelle an Oscar nomination.

So who's the winner in this nude showdown? Chloe Sevigny, of course, for doing lesbian scenes with both of these Oscar-nominated babes. Might we suggest a third option, Mr. Raimi?

Are you enchanted by Hilary Swank? Wish Michelle Williams would ride your broom? Check out all of their breast nudity right here at MrSkin.com!